Valuing water : a global survey of the values that underpin water decisions
Abstract
Valuing water is gaining popularity among policymakers and academics as a new water management paradigm. However, there is a lack of clarity about how to translate this paradigm into practice. We propose a multifaceted approach to valuing water that considers not just the values that people assign to water, such as its uses and benefits, but also broader personal guiding principles (e.g., security) and governance-related values (e.g., social justice) that underpin decision-making about water. Using an interdisciplinary conceptual framework and data from a global survey among water professionals (N = 293), we provide the first empirical evidence showing how preferences among three archetypical perspectives on water management – (1) controlling water flows through engineering solutions; (2) managing water through market-based mechanisms; (3) working with natural water ecosystems – can be explained by different types of values held by respondents, despite the enormous diversity among water management contexts around the world. The valuing water paradigm thus has an expressly political dimension to it; applying it makes explicit how water management decisions are informed by and may reinforce some values and weaken others. As such, it can be a useful diagnostic in the context of water conflicts, to help understand how decisions about water are linked to different stakeholder groups’ values. Valuing water may thus involve balancing conceptually contrasting values and preferences. It also requires the development and application of mechanisms and institutions for effective stakeholder participation in decision-making, especially in the context of significant power differentials between relevant stakeholders.
Citation
Schulz , C , Wolf , L J , Martin-Ortega , J , Glenk , K & Gischler , M 2024 , ' Valuing water : a global survey of the values that underpin water decisions ' , Environmental Science and Policy , vol. 153 , 103685 . https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envsci.2024.103685
Publication
Environmental Science and Policy
Status
Peer reviewed
ISSN
1462-9011Type
Journal article
Collections
Items in the St Andrews Research Repository are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Community water governance in Scotland : exploring meaning, practices, and order
Holstead, Kirsty Lee (2023-11-29) - ThesisAmidst concerns about the global climate crisis, water allocation, management and governance have risen to the top of national and international agendas, including in countries traditionally viewed as having abundant water ... -
Substituting freshwater : can ocean desalination and water recycling capacities substitute for groundwater depletion in California?
Badiuzzaman, Pierre; McLaughlin, Eoin; McCauley, Darren (2017-12-01) - Journal articleWhile the sustainability of resource depletion is a longstanding environmental concern, wider attention has recently been given to growing water scarcity and groundwater depletion. This study seeks to test the substitutability ... -
The paradox of water abundance in Mato Grosso, Brazil
Schulz, Christopher; Ioris, Antonio A. R. (2017-10-04) - Journal articleWhile much effort has gone into studying the causes and consequences of water scarcity, the concept of water abundance has received considerably less attention in academic literature. Here, we aim to address this gap by ...