T.S. Eliot among the Metaphysicals
Abstract
Eliot’s admiration for the poetry of the seventeenth century is well known. However, the
several documents that explore the subject (thinly scattered across decades) fail to constitute
a full account. Drawing on manuscript and print sources, and tracing particularly Eliot’s
prose poetics, this thesis redresses the scholarly need for a nuanced account of Eliot’s role
among the Metaphysical poets.
The relationship ran in both directions, most famously in Eliot’s championing of the
poets and his urging that they find a new readership. His part in the revival of Metaphysical
poetry, though, has been greatly exaggerated and the record is here faithfully adjusted. He
was not in any way responsible for that revival, though he is its most important product, as is
shown by a careful reconstruction of turn-of-the-century transcontinental publishing and
reception.
Eliot’s criticism tells its own, largely unexplored story about the Metaphysicals and
their influence on his critical and poetic sensibility. Most scholars, for instance, know that
Eliot loved Donne, but few know the origin of that interest, let alone its brief nature or the
personal reasons that drove him to appreciate the poet’s audacity. Most also know the
Modernist dicta of Tradition, objective correlative and the dissociation of sensibility, but not
the fact that each owes something to Eliot’s thinking about Donne. Engaging with Harvard
class notes, under-consulted textbooks and a close study of Eliot’s articles from the 1910s,
two separate chapters investigate his education and early prose, along with their delicate
dance between impersonality and confessional criticism.
1921-1926 marks a crucial stage in Eliot’s writing, both for his poetry and his
criticism. The Metaphysicals provide the clearest barometer of that change as well as the
space where he approached conversion. This thesis is the first to trace the poets throughout
Eliot’s criticism, one of the first to engage with his Metaphysical-themed Clark Lectures, and
the first to move far past Eliot’s conversion, interpreting George Herbert as typical of his
late mindset. In 1961 Eliot claimed no one had been as influenced by the Metaphysical poets
as he had been. What this thesis offers is not only a more nuanced portrait of that influence
but also a glimpse into the educational, critical and reading cultures of the early 1900s.
Type
Thesis, PhD Doctor of Philosophy
Rights
Embargo Date: Electronic copy restricted indefinitely.
Embargo Reason: Thesis restricted in accordance with University regulations
Collections
Items in the St Andrews Research Repository are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.