Building a New University : a study of the buildings and related interiors at the University of St Andrews, c.1890-1914
MetadataShow full item record
In his Opening Address of the 1910-11 session, Principal Donaldson looked forward with pride and optimism to the ‘500th year of the existence of the University’ of St Andrews. An anniversary that it may not have reached had the intentions of the 1883 Universities (Scotland) Bill to dissolve the University, been enacted. In the twenty-five years of his Principalship, from 1890 – 1915, the University of St Andrews had undergone a transformation from an institution that was struggling financially, with ‘ruinous’ buildings and decreasing student numbers; to a financially stable institution that had expanded on all fronts to lay the foundations of the modern University. In response to the changes instigated by the Universities (Scotland) Act of 1889, and under the determined leadership of James Donaldson, the University of St Andrews had reasserted and redefined its identity. This thesis brings together educational and architectural histories, to examine the influence of the juxtapositions of historic and modern, Scottish and English, on the developing identity of the institution of the University of St Andrews, as it transitioned to the modern era. The thesis takes an interdisciplinary approach in order to investigate the development of the built environment as intertwined with, and as a physical expression of, the changing institutional identity. This thesis studies a selection of new building work, significant refurbishments, and associated interiors or furniture items, created at the University of St Andrews between 1889 and 1914. It examines the relationship between a notable period of building activity and the educational, institutional, and sociological changes that took place. It concentrates on the developing University purpose, as well as architectural preferences of the time that came together to define the multi-layered identity of the newly-formed University of St Andrews. Through each of the case studies, this thesis examines the implications of the 1889 Act in prompting Principal Donaldson and his colleagues to pursue physical expansion. As such, links between the buildings and the changing concept of university education are highlighted, alongside the greater influence of donors and philanthropists such as the Marquis of Bute and Andrew Carnegie, and the University’s freedom to choose its architects, who range from the nationally acclaimed figures of Robert Rowand Anderson and Robert Lorimer, to local house designers Gillespie & Scott and Mills & Shepherd. The works are examined against the backdrop of the period’s architectural emphasis on a national style relying on historic examples, and the potential conflict this brought with it between style and function, preservation and modernisation. The attempts of the architects to express the University identity within the context of Scotland’s oldest University and a developing modern purpose are compared and evaluated as a parallel to the complex delineations of Scottish and English education systems that dominated much of the debate on university reform at the same time. In conclusion, the works are re-considered together as a narrative for this important period of change, when the University of St Andrews was striving to flourish in response to modern needs and expectations. In doing so, it claims the recognition due to Principal James Donaldson as the most influential figure in this process to resurrect the fortunes of the University.
Thesis, PhD Doctor of Philosophy
Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 Internationalhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
Embargo Date: 2026-05-25
Embargo Reason: Thesis restricted in accordance with University regulations. Restricted until 25th May 2026
Except where otherwise noted within the work, this item's licence for re-use is described as Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International
Items in the St Andrews Research Repository are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Taylor, Laurel (University of St Andrews, 2001) - ThesisThis thesis compares two novels each by Nigerian writer Ben Okri and Moroccan writer Tahar Ben Jelloun. By examining apparently transformative moments in the lives of each protagonist, Azaro and Zahra, its principal aim ...
Tadeo Fuica, Beatriz (University of St Andrews, 2014) - ThesisThis thesis investigates fifty years of Uruguayan cinema in order to revisit the relationship between cinema and nation, at a time in which transnational flows are putting into question the concept of nation and, more ...
Impressions of Montserrat : a partial account of contesting realities on a British dependent territory Skinner, Jonathan (1998-05) - ThesisThis thesis portrays a diversity of impressions of Montserrat, a British Dependent Territory (BDT) in the Eastern Caribbean. The thesis is a postmodern rejection of Grand Theory in the Social Sciences. First I interrogate ...